I almost hate to say how good I think Cafe Pacific really is – because to say that it is “great” would be a jinx, and then you’d probably be disappointed. But it is. With all due respect to Oceanaire (the 4-star upstart north of LBJ), Cafe Pacific is arguably the primo seafood restaurant in Dallas.
SETTING - Super elegant Highland Park Village. Bring your best credit card.
APPETIZERS - The BBQ Spiced Atlantic Sea Scallops with Warm Spinach Blue Cheese Salad & Lemon Butter Sauce are absolutely over-the top. The "Cafe Pacifico" Crab Cakes with Cucumber Salad are another winner. If you just came into an inheritance, try the caviar (type and price seems to vary according to availability) for $75-$110 an ounce. Or build-your-own fresh seafood appetizer plate at ala carte prices. Even the smoked salmon (with capers, onions, watercress, and a sprinkling of fresh dill) was better-than-average. Wow. And that's just the starters.
ENTREES - Every time I finish an appetizer, I think “The entrée can’t possibly match up”. But it does. The Three Onion Crusted Sea Bass with Sweet Corn Risotto and Ancho Cream ($33) is their most popular dish. No surprise. The Short Smoked Salmon with Shoestring Potatoes was equally outstanding. Then there’s the Lobster Trio (three tails, dangling out of the shells) on White Truffle Risotto, with drawn butter ($39). Whoa! Nearly half the menu is non-seafood, including a 3” thick (I’m only exaggerating slightly) Filet Mignon – charred to perfection on the outside, done as you like it on the inside. Available lightly crusted with black pepper or without. Overall price range: $20-$40.
WINE - Many very good wines by the glass. And by the bottle or glass, the prices are so modest that it's startling. They also have a top-end Reserve List, if you're so inclined.
AMBIANCE - Black-and-white marble floors, heavy wood paneling, well-placed beveled-glass dividers between the tables. Combined with the wait-staff in white jackets and white aprons, it speaks of Paris or old New York. The bar is classic. The crowd is well-heeled. The service is silky-smooth. Twenty years ago, this was more of a coat-and-tie place, but the attire these days just ranges from “dressy casual” to "sport jacket". No shorts.
RESERVATIONS - Highly recommended.
BOTTOM LINE - I’ll be brief - You will not be disappointed in Cafe Pacific. ’Nuff said.